Squarespace vs. WordPress: What to Do When Your Site Gets Shut Down

Is your website suddenly gone? Don’t panic. Here’s how to recover — and why WordPress might be your best move.

TL;DR: Site Down? Here’s What to Do

  • Try to reactivate your Squarespace subscription quickly
  • Use tools like Archive.org to recover lost content
  • Switch to WordPress for long-term control and flexibility
  • Book a free 30-min consult with Digital Habitat to get expert help fast

Why This Happens More Often Than You Think

If you’re a small business owner, coach, or freelancer using Squarespace, you may have recently discovered your site is no longer live — maybe the subscription lapsed, billing failed, or you missed an alert. Suddenly, your online presence disappears. 😬

This is more common than you think. And the worst part? Once your Squarespace site expires, recovering your content isn’t always straightforward.

So what now?

Step 1: Don’t Panic — Can You Recover It?

Before you rebuild from scratch, try these options:

  • ✅ Reactivate Your Subscription
    If it’s been only a few weeks, Squarespace may still store your data. Log in and check.
  • 🕵️‍♂️ Use the Wayback Machine (Archive.org)
    Type in your old URL — you may find cached snapshots of your pages.
  • 💾 Check for Backups
    Do you have saved versions of your content, emails with images, or exported data?

If none of this works, don’t worry — rebuilding might actually be a smart move.

Should You Stay with Squarespace or Switch to WordPress?

Here’s a quick side-by-side to help you decide:

FeatureSquarespaceWordPress (with Digital Habitat)
Monthly Cost$16–$49/moHosting from €5/mo
Design Flexibility❌ Limited, template-based✅ Full creative freedom
Ownership & Control❌ Platform-locked✅ You own it all
SEO Customization❌ Basic✅ Advanced (Yoast, RankMath, etc.)
Scalability🚫 Limited growth options✅ Scales as your business grows
SupportChat/email onlyDedicated expert (us!)

“A client of ours, Anna, had her Squarespace fitness site taken offline after a billing error. She lost weeks of bookings. We helped her recover content via the Wayback Machine, rebuilt it on WordPress, and she was live again in 3 days — with more traffic and control than ever.”

Why WordPress is Smarter for Long-Term Growth

WordPress is open-source — meaning you’re not locked into a single provider. You own everything, from your content to your hosting.

That means:

  • More freedom to design and add features
  • Lower long-term costs
  • Stronger SEO tools to help clients find you
  • Easier integrations for payments, booking, and marketing

What to Do Next — A 3-Step Recovery Plan

  1. Book a Free 30-Minute Consultation with Digital Habitat
    We’ll assess your situation and guide you through the next steps.
  2. Rebuild on WordPress with Confidence
    We’ll create a beautiful, mobile-optimized site with total control.
  3. Protect Your New Website for the Future
    We include secure hosting, backups, and maintenance so you’re never caught off guard again.

Let’s Bring Your Website Back — Stronger Than Ever

Every day your site is down, you’re losing potential clients and visibility. We’ll help you bounce back — fast.

🎁 Book your FREE 30-minute consultation today and get expert guidance + actionable recovery tips.

Still not sure? Ask yourself: Would you rather stay dependent on one platform… or finally take control of your online presence?
Let Digital Habitat help you build something that lasts.